My transition from a Catholic to just a Christian and eventually an Agnostic has been a frustrating one in one sense and a liberating one in another. I live in a personal world surrounded by well meaning Christians, family and friends a like, but also in a rational world where people have to play by the rules of reality. I understand the role religion plays in people's lives and in no way would I want to take that away from anybody. It gives people hope, comfort and meaning. Answers to questions they don't understand. Certainty in times of crisis. The very beliefs themselves lead to the courage to pursue many dreams and recognize the blessings that happen in our lives. But if it were that simple, then I'd just buy in and what would be the harm? Religion also limits people, makes them prey to charlatans, lets them justify things that are not rational and are sometimes evil. Makes some people self righteous and judgmental. Fosters hyprocricy and self serving interpretations of their faith. The issue is complicated to say the least.
I grew up with religion being a huge part of my life, though my family wouldn't call it religion, but faith. I was lucky enough to not be in a strict guilt driven dogmatic Catholic family, but in a very Jesus is love type atmosphere. I was blessed for not having the wrath of God and sin and hell being used repeatedly as strong scare tactics. My mom and her sisters had a strong faith in God and never let me forget it. How many times can you be told that Jesus is your Lord and Savior before starting to take offense that they must think you didn't get that or any of the other messages they loved to share with you each time they saw you? When the advice you get to all of life's problems is to pray and have faith, you tend to do that first before you even ask for advice, but somehow that is still the same advice you get anyway as if it ended there.
It wasn't too bad learning about stories of Jesus at the same time I believed in the tooth fairy and the magic of Santa. It was all amazing stuff and as a child a very enticing fanciful world. The problem for me came from asking questions about it. It wasn't that it was forbidden, it was just that it showed a lack of faith and indignation. In my opinion, there were also never any answers. They always came down to feeling the holy spirit and having faith. It is hard to disagree with a person who is so passionate, yet it never added up for me. As a child I saw that Christianity was divided into so many sects that I didn't understand how they could be wrong and right at the same time. I asked what the difference between Catholics and Baptists and Methodists, etc were and I was just told that all that mattered was the Bible and believing in the word of the Lord and that Jesus can see what is in your heart. I had to deal with the contradictory message that if you sinned you risked going to hell and the message that everyone can be saved and goes to heaven. I say this because every time I asked if a certain person probably went to hell, I was told that only God would know that. Well of course, but I was just told that if I didn't follow certain rules or commandments then I risked going, so there were rules I thought. In their effort to not be damnation type of Christian, I quickly saw that nothing was consistent and every question was referred back to the word of God (Bible) and God's love. It was like trying to understand Jello, a teaching where the goal posts always seemed to be moving and it was my fault for not keeping up. So I just took the good, ignored the bad (ie most of the old Testament) and lived my life with a strong faith in God, but a deep dislike for people who preached to me and thought they understood God's message. I resented going to Vacation Bible school and did not like going to Church. True, being lazy was involved, but I did not gain much from it because I didn't fully buy into the premise. Luckily, while I was in my early teens my mom switched from the Catholic church to a string of non-denominational churches before settling on the one that she has been going to for decades. I decided to stay Catholic and protest attending her church and was then I was somewhat free from the indoctrination for the rest of my life.
So I went through my life as a non-practicing Catholic, cafeteria to the extent I used the name. I would not take communion after making my first, because I did not believe in confession and respected the rules. I excommunicated myself early. It was more a cultural thing to me than a spiritual one. The more I learned about religion and read the Bible and heard others talk about it, I knew that this group of people did not represent me. Christians generally, not Caltholics. People like Benny Hinn asking for money on TV, and generally watching how many people's words did not match up to their actions. I judge people not on their faith, but how they live their lives. I know some adamant Christians who live lives that I not only admire and respect, but aspire to, but I also have seen so many scripture spitting people whose lives I do not find Christian-like in the least. The problem is that the people who I admire are not limited to only Christians, but also include other faiths and those people seem to be few and far between. My faith of course would not be dependent on the fact that so many people can be ignorant and hateful.
When I meet a person, I do not care about your words or your magic you can swear faith to, but I only care about your actions. The things you do to make the world a better place, the way you live your life and who you are as a person. Going on and on about Satan and demons which I'm told are very real doesn't help me at all. Saying those same Christian talking points over and over do not give me peace, but only show me that you believe these things.
Another thing I have to say is that culturally I still feel I'm a Christian, the same way that culturally I'm still a Catholic. It was an important part of my life, true or not. This doesn't mean that I really believe that any of it is factual, but it is just part of the community that I live in. At the same time I identify with being Christian, in no way so I identify with the religious right.
We get to the issue that if there really is this divine being, I really feel they would forgive me for coming to the most logical conclusion considering the evidence in front of me, that I just don't know. The facts in front of me are so contradictory and outlandish that it does not deserve my devotion and blind faith in believing those tenets. I think it clear by all the factions in one religion that there is no agreement. If these rules are as important as they sad to be, then it matters what faction you pick. If it is not that important, then those rules can't be true. I believe that if the Lord knows your heart, then he would probably respect accepting that I don't have the answers rather than claiming certainty. My God just wouldn't be so insecure and vain as to need and want my worship in exchange for love.
There are certain religions where it is just clear to many that they are completely made up. Scientology is bullshit as are Mormons some would say. I mean the latter to my understanding has the garden of Eden being located in Missouri, is predominately white people from Utah and Idaho and just got the divine intervention that let them accept blacks in 1979. I don't mean to slander, it could be true I don't know, but man is it fanciful. At least it is rooted in Christianity, but Scientology, hell its based on a science fiction book and the majority of people find that to be comical, that most of us can agree on. They both can't be right. On Mormonism, I don't understand the religion as in depth as I would wish I will admit, but I will say it has some of the most devoted followers I've met. The people I have met in my life that were Mormon where always so smart, educated and good moral people. That might say a lot about the Church and the people in it, but nothing about the religion being factual. Culturally though, this group has done really well for themselves, and morally on some issues they are commendable and well in my opinion on other issues the stance the church takes are morally reprehensible. I think that if you apply the same standards you use to look at other faiths to your own and it just can't hold water. So to easily brush aside a religion out of hand, means I should take that same type of look to my own.
There are all these people of strong faith and they all disagree, yet are all so sure of themselves. I'd love to be in a room with a Jehovah Witness, a Evangelical, a Baptist and a Catholic all debating on the correct way to go to heaven. If it doesn't truly matter which faith you choose, then the dogma they teach you, that differs must not be correct. In theory, in my example, at least 3 of those are completely wrong about their dogma and teaching and this isn't small stuff, it is about how you enter the kingdom of heaven. That is kind of a big deal, or it should be. It just highlights the point that we don't really know and wanting to know and having faith you know are not the same.
The one thing I did know as I was on my spiritual journey was that although it is either evolutionarily within me or part of my early Christian indoctrination, but I have a belief in God. That said, everything else, I just don't know. It is easy to prove so many things being contradictory, self serving, and false, but it doesn't change that fact that I don't know. Hearing other people talk to me like they do know, just insults me. I mean, the very act of questioning and having doubt is viewed as a lack of faith. I get miracles thrown in my face all the time as if that somehow explains why I should believe that Leviticus is the word of God, yet somehow we don't have to follow it because Jesus fixed that. I digress.
I'll say again, that I'll always believe in a God, that is something I can't move past. It is probably built into my brain. Now I fight with that, and I know I'll get an answer (or non answer) once I cease to exist. But to go around saying I know what God says or I know what the rules of the game are, considering how they have changed so much, not even just over the centuries, but over the decades. I still catch myself praying all the time, it brings me comfort, but in no way proves that what I was taught is gospel truth. (Like how I used gospel there?)
I also find it frustrating when you are trying to figure something out in life and people just default to their spirituality as the answer. For me it is just giving up, the lazy way out. God will provide I'm told, but somehow only because I'm special since clearly there are people in much greater need. This of course I have to understand as something I don't understand because God works in mysterious ways. Maybe that was the point all along. If I need help trying to study for a test, I'm not just going to put it in God's hands or pray about it, I'm going to try to do proactive actions to fix the problem. If God wants to help or bless me, I'd be happy, but its just so lazy to go around answering everything with God will provide. Christians love the story of the man on the roof during the flood and each time a person comes to save him he says that God will come. When the man drowns, God tells him he sent multiple people to save him. It is a great story about taking your life into your own hands and being proactive.
Speaking of stories, the answers and responses I get from Christians are taking points I've heard so many times over it frustrates me to hear them. There are just lines that people love to use. "You are telling me we came from monkeys? We were made in God's image." I was once explained how the scientific theory of evolution was flawed because of the complexity of the human eye as if it was a thoughtful insight, not just one of the points debunked from the creationist book About Humans and Pandas. There is an amazing documentary I recommend on the Dover School case on PBS NOVA. http://video.pbs.org/search/Dover This is just another example that proves that what people take as faith can have no basis in reality and still be believed in like gospel. (once again, I find it awesome that gospel can be used for truth.)
There are also many things in life that are out of our control. We all have to accept that. How do we feel like we have some semblance of control? We pray and ask others to pray for us. Now I understand the peace that praying brings a person, but from what I have read it has been proven to make no improvement in medical status (unless the person knows they are being prayed for). And then you get your prayer group together, you pray and honor the Lord and by chance things turn out badly. Well it was God's plan, so you just accept it. Well then why were you praying in the first place against his plan? It was God's plan and your praying for God to follow his own plan isn't going to make him do so, since he is doing so already. Bad = God's plan. Good = Prayer helped and God's plan. (Good = not God's plan, but he changed his mind due to your prayer. This is one you don't hear often, but seems inferred.) I know more than anyone the peace and comfort prayer brings and the few times your wishes comes true how it makes you feel like your prayers were answered. You also accept the times they did not come true as it being out of your control. I worry talking about prayer because I personally believe that praying has benefits that can be proven, but they in my opinion have a lot more to do with psychology and state of mind than magical intervention. I would not want to discourage anyone from praying, since I still do, but you can use it an example on proving that your Good Shepard teachings and beliefs are therefore correct.
People should believe what they want and faith has inspired people to do such wonderful things, but it is also something that in the hands of ignorant people frustrates me and has caused much harm in history. I think everyone understands many examples of this. From increasing the spread of AIDs in Africa by moving to abstinence only education programs, and for the same reasons that we have more teen moms in more religious states then in others. We deny people the right to marry because of interpretations of the Bible (ie interracial), and we use the parts that suit us and ignore the parts that don't suit it as well. The political right has used the Bible but not the parts I really like focusing on helping the poor but, parts which are non-violent to justify war, parts that oppress women to well oppress women. So many good messages in the book and even those are put aside so we can only focus on abortion. And don't get me started on the mixture of religion and nationalism, which I find horrendous as I would hope we were all God's children around the globe.
It is easy to see how radical Islamic people of such strong faith committing acts of terror are in the wrong, but I worry because it takes that kind of irrational thinking and faith in a man's interpretation of words thousands of years old to make such destruction and hurt innocent people. Religions can make good people do terrible things and helps some bad people do worse things.
I remember thinking growing up that I was just so lucky to be born into the right faction of the right religion that has the answers of what God really wants and what we need to do to have good things happen after we die. You know to be in the correct demonmination of the correct faith. It is just mathematically unfeasble but hey, maybe I was so lucky, but when I sit down look at it, I just can't agree. Little did I know when I was older the question wouldn't be which faith, but religion or no religion.
Now people always wonder where you can get your sense of morality if not from God. There are books written on this topic by expects, but I did not get my morals from the Bible. Lessons yes, but there is no way I'm giving up my daughter to be raped to protect an angel. (tell me if I'm misinterpreting that story.) I'm sorry, but my views of what is right and wrong are not based on the Bible, they are based on my personal convictions about being a human being and member of society. I had good parents that thought me right from wrong and in the process of growing up I made my own distinctions. I don't try to not commit sin only because it would upset God, I do it because it is the right thing to do and in my opinion the most healthy way to live my life. You don't need a Bible for morality. Laws maybe, but that is another social contract type discussion for another day.
Don't get me started on the Cameron video asking people if they think they are good people and showing them that they are all sinners and have committed many crimes in their hearts and that if they do not become more hardcore Christians then they risk not being saved or left behind. Bible or no Bible, we do not understand how Santa's naughty list, I mean the heaven or hell score card works and I'd appreciate it if people stopped telling they understand it and using it to threaten me.
Now this isn't a scientific paper on why my beliefs are the best and others are wrong, but just a broad brush stroke on why I identify with being Agnostic rather than believing in my heart that the stories people tell about what it means to be Christian are true. You can throw my misinformation in my face and I admit, I'm probably ignorant on many issues as far as the facts relating to faith, but the bigger questions, those are the ones that make me state that I really don't know.
When people say, "God says..", "God wants,.." all I get is angry, the part of me that believes in God thinks, "What dare you even think you have the right to speak for God. God's words are not your self serving, self placating thoughts that exist in your head." No one person has any more right to speak for God than that next. Anytime a person does so, its just an insult to the true almighty power that God has. You do not know, and if you wanted to say, "I think God would say, ..." fine, but "God wants me to ... (or) God has put .... in my path" are just using God for your own selfish means. God doesn't care who wins football games, but I wouldn't know. Does that mean since they both prayed that God actually cared who won? Does God actually intervene in sports, war or politics? If so, take the good with the bad then, instead of picking what God approves of and what he doesn't. God elected Bush I was told, but not Obama. Such crap.
This is just the way I personally choose to believe, I don't care about going around the world trying to convert the world to believe they don't know either. If you want to believe that your denomination of your religion only gets to go to heaven, that is great. that works for a lot of people. They will live very happy, spiritually fulfilling lives. That is just not the way I want to go. The question is also, how you raise your kids. I definitely want my kids to be well versed in Christianity. I want them to know all the stories, have a firm understanding of the bible, its positive and inspirational messages and also its horrible stories and endless contradictions. Mainly as a tool to understand where everyone else is coming from so that they don't have to worry about being talked down to with the bible, they can see, this is sexist, this is morally inconsistent, this is ok with what? I'm supposed to do what? I'm not going to teach them about Jesus when they learn about Santa, I won't indoctrinate, I'll let them decide for themselves. Spirituality is a person's personal journey and maybe they will take on the religion.
Now there is the phirrah issue. Growing up, people always equated not believing in God with Satanism. Atheist was a bad word having to do with the devil. Questioning made you a bad person, but to not believe made you a terrible person . You were ostracized for being atheist. Everything else is forgiven, but atheism was not, unless you repented of course. Then you are taken in and prayed for. Oh we will pray away the doubt, the questions, the logic. It must be what gays feel like when people try to pray away their demons. We will help you see the light and healing. For me it is just insulting. I could play that same game too, I could become Jehovah Witness tomorrow and pray for your soul to be saved if only you saw the light, this one correct way of believing. I don't have the energy to play the I'm more spiritual than you game. We'll have a prayer war.
Growing up, my dad was always demonized for not being crazy extroverted about his faith. He grew up in the Catholic faith and has stayed true to that to this day. That always bothered me because I knew how strong his faith was. When I was older I sat down with him and talked to him about his faith and pin down his views and I was disappointed that he too believed the dogma, he just wasn't the type that wanted to stand up and dance about feeling the spirit. He was way too religious for my tastes, but somehow still not religious enough for others. Now if he was treated that way and he believes in all this, imagine a person like me who comes out and says that he doesn't buy what you are selling.
I'm coming to terms with being agnostic. I just don't know, but at the same time I can clearly see how a lot of what you say is not true. If you can't be true to yourself and the people around you, what kind of life are you living? I need to be true to myself now.
When I mention the hypocrisy and things that annoy me about certain Christan tactics, it doesn't mean that that is why I choose to be an Agnostic. It is not a reaction to them, but the part of my brain that doesn't understand how the universe works and is OK with that. That wants to life a good life without having to pretend to be something I'm not. This isn't a crisis of faith or being brainwashed by a religion, since I know don't identify with any one. People have told me that I just don't have the balls to be atheist. They make great points and as an Agnostic I think they could be right as well about not believing in a God or a flying spaghetti monster, or unicorns. But I have no reason to be certain and maybe the doubt they could be wrong and there is a God is still too strong inside me. Who am I to say? I'm just one person, but I'm just as qualified as the next to speak on matters of faith and belief.
These of course are my thoughts and feelings at this moment and there are probably contradictory statements and things I got very wrong. Nothing I have said proves that God does not exist, nor would I think it to. I may still have faith about that, but no true logical reason to justify it. That being the case, I'm not going to try to convince others to believe like me. This is everyone's personal journey. This is not meant to offend or to start a debate. It is just my attempt a map on explaining how I got to where I am. That just highlights that fact that I don't know and no amount of preaching and praying for me is going to change the fact that I can't know the unknown and nor will I pretend to.